Skip to content
TRIPOLI · BENGHAZI
Itkan | إتقانLAW FIRM — HomeContact

Corporate & finance

The interest prohibition and Libyan funds abroad: November 2019 commentary

An article from 2019 discussing the ban on usurious transactions and its effects on Libyan banks and funds abroad.

A financial book, an hourglass, and measuring instruments next to crossing stones leading to a banking building.
Editorial illustration

Legislative implications for Law No. (1) of 2013 AD regarding the prevention of usurious transactions

Legislation and application requirements

No one disputes the prohibition of usury, even though the prohibition was limited to its religious dimension, and its economic dimension was not controlled in our contemporary world today.

I imagine that no one opposes enacting a law prohibiting usury, on professional and practical grounds. The situation that makes the debate machine may be attracted to the extent of the practicality of implementing the law itself in accordance with the human capabilities and practical capabilities currently available in Libya, to the extent that - that is, activating the law - has truly become a daily concern for companies and banks. When enacting the law, it was necessary to take into account the time stages required for its implementation, which would not harm existing interests and stable legal positions, especially if the implementation of the law itself was retroactive. The law approved the immediate and retroactive effect of its provisions, that is, at the beginning of 2013 for natural persons in their dealings with legal persons, and at the beginning of 2015 AD between legal persons among themselves.

The question for the Libyan legislator is, has he taken into account that the banks and companies operating in Libya are not ready for such a step within two years, and can the Libyan economic system in general and the banking system in particular carry out this reform within the time period granted, which will truly inflict - and actually incur - the Libyan economy unconsidered financial losses. It will expose the funds of the Libyan state abroad to a fundamental legal problem, as any revenues coming from interest in the eyes of the law are illegal amounts, but rather funds that are the crime of dealing in usury according to this law, including funds that are not yet due due to the retroactivity of the law itself to the past. This is a loophole that foreign countries or institutions may rely on to deprive Libya of the interest on its funds deposited abroad, especially the funds of the Central Bank, the Libyan Investment Authority, the Libyan Foreign Bank, and the rights of the National Oil Corporation.

If we look at Islamic countries such as Malaysia and Bahrain, despite their progress over two decades or more in building a base for dealing with Islamic financial instruments, they still rely on both traditional and Islamic banking systems, and therefore it is better for Libya to adopt the same approach, especially since it lacks the cadres and financial tools for such modernization or legislative reform.

Anyone who follows the method of voting and the process of passing this law - on the air - and in the circumstances of the year 2013, and with the mechanism of raising hands without the presence of technology and secrecy in conducting the voting process, will become clear to him the dimensions and background of the existence of this law, which did not take into account the negative effects of its application, especially the economic ones, on state institutions.

Libyan funds abroad

In other words... the funds of the Central Bank of Libya, estimated at approximately one hundred billion US dollars, as well as the funds of the Libyan Investment Corporation (cash) of approximately fifteen billion US dollars deposited with the Central Bank of Libya, three billion in deposits called (fixed income), and about five billion US dollars between so-called financial derivatives and securities (Derivatives, Swaps). & Options). They all depend on an international usury-interest system through which returns are earned, especially the funds of the Central Bank of Libya and the Libyan Foreign Bank.

 The question that arises is what is the legal qualification of these interests with usurious transactions - that is, the so-called profits - on deposits and investments that depend on the investment and financial categories referred to in accordance with Law No. (1) of 2013 AD? Is it illegal, but rather a crime, in which the elements of the crime are present, and this crime extends to the receipt of these funds as well for the years prior to the issuance of the law. The legal offense is borne by these institutions, represented by criminal convictions on their heads and boards of directors. The Public Prosecution, led by the Public Prosecutor’s Office, must file a criminal case against them. Rather, the issue does not stop there, as the issue becomes more complicated and the problem becomes even more complicated if we take the opinion of the Fatwa Council or the Mufti in the State of Libya, who may not have heard this legal violation after this, and that most of Libya’s money coming from oil is invested through the Central Bank, the Foreign Bank, and the Libyan Investment Corporation with a usurious interest system.

On the other hand, the foreign party, a bank or an investment fund, may use the excuse of not paying these profits to Libyan institutions because they are headquartered in Libya and were established according to Libyan laws - taking into account the agreement on the application of another law in concluded contracts - and therefore we cannot violate Libyan law, which considers paying interest a crime and with a retroactive date, in addition to that the statute of limitations in the criminal aspect does not apply in Libya. What further complicates the problem is the conflict between the entry into force of Law No. (7) of 2015 issued by the House of Representatives to postpone the entry into force of Law No. (1) of 2013 AD for a period of five years, that is, to the year 2020 AD, and the ruling of the Supreme Court to cancel the amendment to the Seventh Constitutional Declaration in 2014 AD, and the failure of the Law Department of the Supreme Judicial Council or the Supreme Court to express a legal opinion on it. All in light of the constitutional vacuum due to the absence of a legislative authority to carry out this task due to the technical failure to complete the Skhirat political agreement constitutionally.

Judicial position

However, the Supreme Court in its Civil Appeal No. 467 - 64 Q dated 6/16/2019 AD resolved this legal dilemma regarding the legality of the aforementioned Law No. 7 of 2015 by ignoring the existence of the law in the first place. What is understood from this approach is the Supreme Court’s bias in its ruling in its constitutional appeal No. 17 - 61 Q dated 11/6/2014. M, by canceling the paragraph from the Constitutional Declaration and withdrawing legitimacy from the House of Representatives, and relying only on Law No. 1 of 2013 as a reference in this context by reversing any amendment to it later. However, the Supreme Court - and it did well in its graduation - in restricting the provisions of the application of the provisions of Law No. 1 of 2013 by considering the benefits resulting from delay fines under Article 229 of the Civil Code not subject to the provisions of this law and thus giving the possibility of agreement and It is a crime.

Where are we regarding the law and Sharia regarding Libya’s foreign funds?

Article contributors

What does this mean for your business?

Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.

Discuss this topic