Investment & market entry
Public–private partnerships in Libya
A legal approach to partnership between the public and private sectors and the impact of the absence of legislation regulating it on development in Libya.

The concept of partnership and its importance
The reader may have a number of questions about what is partnership? And who are its parties? What is the reason for its existence? Is it a legal product?
The partnership of the public and private sectors has become a practical pattern in moving the wheel of development and an engine for the economy with the lowest costs, the best services, and the highest quality, with limited or no corruption, especially in countries like Libya. There are many experiences and great lessons learned from implementing these forms of atypical contracts in a business environment that really needs an opportunity to create a field for professionalism and an arena for competitiveness.
The traditional pattern - in Libya - depends on contracts awarded by public sector entities in Libya under the Administrative Contracts Regulations without taking into account investment exits, as well as the fair distribution and sharing of legal and commercial risks with contractors, so that the state ends up bearing all or most of the obligations, including financial spending from public treasury resources on projects with high cost and low quality. Perhaps the lesson learned after 2011 is the reluctance of foreign companies to return to completing the project. Its contractual obligations in infrastructure projects due to force majeure are a lesson to be learned, especially since the Libyan state bore in advance the financial costs of the implemented projects at rates reaching an average of 15% of the value of the total contracts estimated at approximately 150 billion Libyan dinars. In other words, if Libya had adopted the contracting pattern known as a partnership between the two sectors (PPP), we would not have fallen into this very costly pitfall and the negotiations that would entail it to rebalance the contracts financially and legally, and the technical and construction impact of not completing construction for a period of over seven years.
The need for a legal framework
The Libyan state actually lacks a legal framework to regulate the partnership between the two sectors. In light of the absence of legislative and professional evidence in regulating such relationships or contractual patterns, which could be the engine in achieving growth and securing financing at the lowest costs, especially since Libya has once again slipped to a rate of (7 out of 7) in the country risk classification after it approached the rate of 4 in the year 2010, that is, what is called “Country Risk Classifications.”
In this context, it is worth noting the Libyan conference that was organized with an international presence in 2013, with technical and coordination support from Clyde & Co. Law Firm and Legal Consultations - Libya, and under the auspices of the Ministry of Housing and Utilities, with an international presence of PPP supervisors in a number of countries, including Egypt, Finland, and Britain, as well as the World Bank, and an extensive presence of interested Libyan elites and personalities, led by a number of members of the General National Congress and a deputy governor. The Central Bank of Libya and ministers of the Libyan government, in order to review the experiences of the participating countries in how to deal with these unconventional patterns in contracting and completing public projects in order to submit their proposals regarding the draft law related to the partnership between the public and private sectors in Libya, the subject of the conference, and submitted by some members of the General National Congress.
However, the reality is otherwise - and as usual - all studies and the outputs of international consultants that cost the state money and time are thrown away on shelves and not even used as a reference. We were actually aware of this matter, so we anticipated this with a practical proposal to the Minister of Housing and Utilities to begin cultivating a culture of partnership by forming a small team in the ministry, to be developed into one unit, then a division, and a department in the medium term, to establish the nucleus and a database for the pattern and guide of partnership, and thus be a platform from which the Libyan state will start in the coming years in legitimizing these contractual patterns.
Investment proposals
This proposal was followed by another meeting that took place in London in the same year with both the Undersecretary of the Ministry of Housing and Utilities and the Director General of the Infrastructure Authority regarding the necessity of employing the assets owned by the Authority, estimated at approximately 30 billion Libyan dinars, and the Ministry’s assets estimated at approximately 60 billion Libyan dinars, and not to wait for financial support from the state, which will decrease significantly or dry up, through introducing different types of contracting such as PPP through four stages starting with an independent assessment of the assets according to The market price entails, secondly, addressing the legal aspects with contractors and implementers, especially foreign companies, and classifying and grouping similar assets into medium and small investment categories. Thirdly, to finally be sold directly to investors, whether Libyan or foreign.
With this, the state can obtain additional income from this sale, and most importantly, it stimulates market movement, especially by small contractors and merchants, to revive whether in construction or imports through the banking system and revive the real estate market through the clean real estate system in terms of the legal status of real estate ownership of these assets. All on the condition that it is done - as one package - and transparently by creating a website on the international network to download all bids and contracts and their details so that everyone can monitor them (a proposal presented to the Minister of Economy in 2012).
This proposal had two parts, the first in small and medium investment categories, which are dealt with on a direct basis. As for infrastructure projects, such as airports, ports, large shopping centers, and the like, they should be dealt with under the PPP system, because they will be owned by the state according to the agreed-upon and internationally recognized period of 20-25 years.
Libyans should understand that most of the projects implemented in developed and developing countries, including cities, free zones, airports, ports, hotels, power stations, roads, and even prisons in Britain, are managed by the private sector for periods of time after they are owned by the state. The mechanism used in implementing and financing the project is simply called Project Finance, which is based on the idea of everyone watching everyone, from an investor, a bank, a contractor, a beneficiary, or the state..... The return is paid over the time of the agreement from the returns of the project itself, and it is the guarantor, and therefore does not cost the state any expenses or obligations it bears for the project.
Conclusion
In conclusion, I hope that there will actually be a move to pass such a law soon after the political breakthrough in Libya so that it will be the engine of the non-rentier national economy, and at the same time achieve a transformation in traditional contracting models and similar negative drawbacks in high cost, poor quality, the possibility of corruption, and the search for financial financing for them, to new patterns that future generations will follow, similar to the rest of the countries that have taken them, and for us in the experiences of others, a lesson to emulate.
Al-Boudiry slide
Lawyer/former university professor
Article contributors
What does this mean for your business?
Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.
Discuss this topic




