Public law & citizenship
Formulating administrative decisions: accuracy and professionalism
Comment on the importance of accuracy and professionalism in formulating administrative decisions and their legal effects.

Comment context
With the beginning of the political impasse and legislative division in the State of Libya in 2014 AD, I had a stop with an article entitled “The Law Industry is a Profession and Professionalism.” Today we stand before the threshold of unifying the state of institutions and social and cultural components under the government of national unity, which is truly on the political and economic, as well as social, frontiers based on the basis of national reconciliation and cultivating a culture of citizenship and concepts of peaceful coexistence socially. Rather, legally, and this is what concerns me as a lawyer and jurist. I am keen that the new government does not make the mistakes of previous governments. It must improve the selection of its advisors, especially those who make strategies and policies, despite the limited duration of the government, and the necessity of it focusing on the priorities known as the trinity: the political and institutional division, the Corona pandemic, and the economic bottlenecks.
The decision in question
The subject of this alert is due to the fact that the Prime Minister of the National Unity Government issued Circular No. (03) dated 03-16-2021, addressing the heads of the boards of trustees of institutions and investment funds and the general assemblies of public companies and companies in which the state contributes. The publication has three main drawbacks:
Conditioning, specialization, and time impact
First: The Circular came under the name “Publication” and in reality - in legal terms - it is an “administrative decision” because it does not explain or clarify legal texts or provisions of applicable legislation, but rather establishes provisions that affect acquired or existing legal positions or affect their normal or usual work granted to them by the legislation in force, especially since the text of the “Publication” decision considers the minutes and decisions issued by the boards of trustees of investment institutions and the general assemblies of public companies to be cancelled. Among them are those in which the state contributes a specific percentage, which may force the remaining shareholders, as well as third parties in general, to dispute the state before the courts.
Second: The circular was issued by the head of government, i.e. the Prime Minister, in his capacity, and not by the Council of Ministers in session, which may create a problem of jurisdiction and the resulting defect in verifying and completing the pillars of the decision itself, and may open the way for it to be appealed before the administrative judiciary in Libya.
Third: The decision takes effect on a retroactive date, that is, from the date of granting confidence to the government on March 10, 2021, which clashes with the validity of the law, as the judiciary of the Libyan Supreme Court - as well as the Egyptian one - settled on (that administrative decisions, organizational or individual, have no effect except from the date of their issuance, taking into account the rule of non-retroactivity of administrative decisions, and in application of the principle of prohibiting infringement on acquired rights or legal positions that have been established and integrated except by law, and therefore administrative decisions must not apply retroactively. Even if it stipulates this effect) the principle of the Supreme Court in Administrative Appeal Case No. 41/55 Q dated 11/30/2008 AD.
He may argue that the circular stipulates that it will be in effect temporarily, or that the state is subject to the application of the emergency law. Both arguments are rejected, as emergency laws are governed by the principle of limitation and timeliness, and they have their own requirements not to prejudice legal positions, except for serious reasons for which we do not see the basis for this decision. As for timing, its existence is not justified because it is a form of evasion of legal responsibility.
Conclusion
As much as we want the government to succeed in unifying the state and its institutions, and we understand the motive behind such practical decisions, it would have been better for it to take care to take into account the current legislation - even though some of it is not in line with the necessities of reform and modernization - in order to achieve harmony with the legal system, by seeking the help of experts in law who have professional experience and not just academic, as long as our goal is to build a state of institutions and law.
Article contributors
What does this mean for your business?
Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.
Discuss this topic




