Skip to content
TRIPOLI · BENGHAZI
Itkan | إتقانLAW FIRM — HomeContact

Litigation & arbitration

Reforming the Libyan Criminal Procedure Code

Observations on the need to modernize the Libyan Code of Criminal Procedure, with a focus on pretrial detention and guarantees of justice.

An old book and an hourglass lie on a stone table, and an open door lights the corridor beyond them.
Editorial illustration

The importance of procedural reform

It is known that the Code of Criminal Procedure and the rules it contains are of great importance in that they govern the behavior that judicial officers, the investigating authority, the judicial authorities, as well as lawyers, must adhere to and abide by while performing their assigned work so that none of them exceeds the limits of the law and is the decisive factor in the relationship between them. However, this does not mean achieving the desired justice unless the stumbles and failures that undermine the principle of justice and in the name of the law are overcome from time to time, and which are revealed during the practical application of the Code of Criminal Procedure, such that its shortcomings and disadvantages become apparent, such that it requires the legislator to intervene to amend or abolish some of these rules in a way that is consistent with the principle of justice, and is consistent with international practices in protecting rights and freedoms, which the State of Libya has ratified most of the international and regional covenants to protect the rights and freedoms related to the human being and his freedom.

Examples of practical problems

Looking at the Libyan Code of Criminal Procedure, it is noted that it has not been modernized or developed, even though it has been issued for a period of approximately seventy years, except for a small amount. Therefore, the legislative authority must intervene with the intention of reforming and refining outdated articles, especially those related to freedom-depriving articles, such as:

  • Not specifying a final period for pretrial detention that cannot be exceeded, as the fate of the accused remains unknown under indefinite detention. Sometimes, pretrial detention exceeds most or all of the period of the sentence prescribed for the crime without the accused being brought to trial. Therefore, the legislator must include in the law a limit on the period of pretrial detention.
  • The indictment chamber judge did not specify a period for filing the reasons for referral to felonies, which contributes to the delay in examining cases while the accused remains in pretrial detention without legal justification, which may last for several months.
  • Article (374) of the Code of Criminal Procedure stipulates  “Provided that the appeal filed by the accused who has been sentenced to an enforceable custodial penalty shall be dropped if he does not submit for execution before the hearing.”This is also the case when appealing against freedom-restricting rulings before the Supreme Court, and from the practical reality it appears - in our estimation - that most cases are ruled to be dropped by the appeal or appeal without it being considered and thus the circle of those wanted by the law enforcement authorities expands without giving those wanted the opportunity to defend themselves while they are on the loose. Rather, practices are led to the necessity of requiring them to surrender themselves before considering the appeal or appeal, which is considered a type of coercion and excess, including It is inconsistent with the principles of justice and preserving the freedom of the accused.

A call for development

All that we have raised is the tip of the iceberg and shortcomings that must be addressed, and there is no objection to resorting to criminal legislation in other countries or calling for conferences and workshops to which all legal professionals, especially lawyers, are invited because they are most closely in touch with the practical reality resulting from the application of the law in its current state, all with the aim of improving the criminal legal texts in the State of Libya so that they are in line with international practices and the human rights and freedoms charters ratified by Libya, which are ratified by Libya. It is not part of the national legislation, but is characterized by legislative supremacy over the laws under the umbrella of the effective Constitutional Declaration of 2011 AD and soon the Permanent Constitution.

Article contributors

What does this mean for your business?

Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.

Discuss this topic