Skip to content
TRIPOLI · BENGHAZI
Itkan | إتقانLAW FIRM — HomeContact

Public law & citizenship

Law-making: Professionalism and Consultation in Preparing Legislation

An article on professionalism in preparing legislation and the importance of consultation and institutional modernization in law-making.

A pen and drafting instruments on sheets of plans, with a building for an institutional meeting behind them.
Editorial illustration

Law-making and Professional Drafting

A law is legislation made within representative assemblies (parliaments), as the principal source of legality in any country. If legislation is an important means of unifying the legal order and legitimacy in the state, and a fundamental factor in achieving national consensus and unity and increasing stability and social peace, that law must accord with society’s spirit and culture and be compatible with its prevailing values and requirements. This enables it to balance different interests, preserve confidence in transactions and acquired legal positions, ensure equal opportunities for all, and help keep the state and its system functioning by encapsulating present realities and a forward-looking vision of the future.

Law-making is policy before it is drafting, and a profession and professional practice before it is imitation and following precedent. It is a yardstick balancing intellectual orientations and factual circumstances within a rigorous, disciplined formal framework. This is a fundamental safeguard for bringing bills into being without the defect of unconstitutionality on the one hand, or the disease of an uncontrolled proliferation of exceptions and amendments on the other. It also saves time and facilitates implementation by the administration and individuals, and enables the judiciary to achieve the intended application and enforcement without inadequacy or ambiguity.

Parliament (the House of Representatives or its equivalent) is the authority entrusted with enacting laws. Today, however, in a number of countries, the preparation of bills has constitutionally become an inherent responsibility of the executive (the government), owing to its knowledge of practical needs and operational policies. What the latter has not grasped in Libya is that law-making and the mechanism through which legislation comes into being require knowledge of other countries’ experiences, beginning with studying the proposed legislation, receiving responses to it and discussing it. The process does not stop at forming a committee or legal working group entrusted with that task, whose work is usually confined to collecting ready-made legislation from other countries and recasting it in a new form that may, in turn, neither reflect nor encapsulate Libyan realities and our society’s cultural particularities.

Participation in Preparing Laws

The situation is further complicated by the failure to enlist the contribution of academics, professionals, business owners and citizens through civil society organizations, and of the state through its institutions, by using electronic media, the press and other media, and by holding specialized workshops and conferences. This should be done even if it takes some time to produce enduring and well-crafted legal work that reflects the requirements of our reality and adopts the philosophy of our future direction, especially during the transitional phase of rebuilding the institutions of the Libyan state. The process concludes with a review by the competent state authorities, provided that consideration is given to implementation proceeding through sufficiently long phases to preserve confidence and the stability of existing legal positions as the legislation enters into force.

In this context, the initiative of a civil society organization, the Libya Center for Arbitration, to hold Libya’s first international arbitration conference at the end of 2017, which put forward the “Draft Libyan Arbitration Bill” for discussion in Arabic and English, reflects the role of civil society organizations, research centers and the private sector generally in adopting and advancing such independent initiatives to help the competent authorities modernize the state’s legal system. It was preceded by the initiative adopted by the Ministry of Housing in cooperation with Clyde & Co law firm, through an international conference centered on a “Draft Bill on Public-Private Partnerships for Libya,” held in Tripoli in 2013.

This approach falls within the government’s objectives in recent years, based on reviewing the legal systems in force. It has issued several decisions focused principally on forming legal committees entrusted with reassessing and preparing bills, and has also sought to strengthen the Law Department at the Supreme Judicial Council with qualified personnel. Yet these efforts truly require thinking “outside the box.” In my experience, the criticism of these legal committees is that many of their members—our colleagues, for whom we have every appreciation and respect—have practiced law for many years, whether in academia, drafting contracts, working in judicial bodies or elsewhere, without opportunities to engage with and learn about others’ experiences through work or travel. Consequently, the anticipated outcomes of these committees in developing the legislative system generally, and the business framework in particular, may have shortcomings: legislative modernization may depart from its purpose, and the expected legislation may be produced in a form that accords with the legal model while substantively contradicting the general objective we seek. That objective is to remake the state’s legislative system with practical capacity to achieve the desired balance between protection and openness, foresight and actual circumstances: foundational principles for a modern civil state in which the private sector plays the principal role in rebuilding the state and driving its economy, bearing in mind the strategy of making Libya the commercial and financial center of North Africa and the southern Mediterranean in the future.

This leads me, in the context of this article, to cite a paper I wrote in 2005, when I was rapporteur and a member of the Libyan-British committee for developing banking and economic legislation in Libya, entitled “Towards a Unified Companies Law in Libya.” In it I proposed several ideas despite an unencouraging legal environment, whose most significant shortcomings included the lack of legislation regulating electronic transactions and commerce in Libya and the absence of legal recognition of electronic evidence. It was therefore a professional obligation to think “outside the box” by employing electronic means, in practice and consistently with the law, in the formation of companies and the publication of their particulars. After discussing the proposal with specialists, particularly technical experts on the Executive Committee for Strategies (succeeded by the Economic Development Board), I concluded that it was possible to build a company formation and registration system through the body of contract drafters using electronic means. God enabled me to propose the creation of the system now known as the “Alghad Business Center,” through which company formation and registration in Libya are accelerated.

Modernizing Practices and Procedures

Today, in this article, I would like to take the opportunity to go further by highlighting the importance of updating current practices, since the post-revolution legal environment may allow us to contribute more by sharing proposals that I hope will reach politicians and decision-makers in Libya. The proposal is to remove the need for an intermediary through contract drafters when forming, registering and amending companies, not only because of the financial or time cost, but also because of the need to speed up procedures through administrative decentralization, as in most advanced economies, from Britain to North America and Japan, and even Singapore and Malaysia.

As an interim step, the Ministry of Economy’s licensing offices in municipalities could be used by connecting them to a central formation and registration system. In the future, the internet could be used within what is known as the e-government program, as is already the case with the Passport Authority’s system or that of the Ministry of Manpower. This would require only payment of the prescribed fees and receipt of the commercial registration as a document containing all business particulars on a single comprehensive sheet. The system for companies and traders should be linked with the Ministry of Interior, the tax authorities, the Central Bank of Libya, manpower authorities and insurance, enabling the state and third parties to view everything relating to the company’s or trader’s commercial license. What encourages this direction is that we are in the process of completing the implementation of the national identification number system in most activities and transactions.

Comparison and Recommendations

Since we are still unable to move beyond the undesirable practice in preparing bills, I might cite here what has happened and continues to happen: from time to time we receive news that a bill is being discussed, or that a small workshop, meeting or conference has been held or organized for it, shortly before the event or while it is taking place. For example, in previous years a government body put forward the idea of preparing a “Draft Commercial Companies Law,” but unfortunately we did not find a copy of the draft until later, and we found nothing of the announced workshop beyond a passing news item on a web page. Are we still working with a mindset of insularity and concealment when studying bills affecting the daily lives of citizens and the state, through absolute secrecy, a blackout of information and committees operating within a single mode of thought?

Should we not learn how others make laws through several levels of discussion and deliberation, with the contribution of all parties? They also follow established procedures for reviewing bills by involving everyone, meaning social and professional groups. Indeed, they go further: in the final drafting stages, they refer the draft legislation to several specialized law offices and firms for their technical opinions, given their practical experience in following the implementation of legislation and legal practice in the state and its sectors. Ultimately, it remains for the legislature to decide what it considers appropriate or otherwise and what serves citizens and the country.

I therefore hope the government will take care not to depart from professional standards and professionalism in law-making on the pretext of time or national priorities, because citizens later pay, in money and time, for the consequences of producing any distorted or defective legislation through an abnormal birth.

In concluding this approach, I recall the importance of addressing the principal difficulty in law-making: the need to answer the essential question, what do we want Libya to be politically and economically as a state? Beginning with agreement on defining this vision necessarily affects the strength of any legislation produced in substantive terms, while its natural birth comes from following professional and practical stages in formal terms.

Albudairi Shariha

Lawyer / Former University Professor

Article contributors

What does this mean for your business?

Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.

Discuss this topic