Intellectual property & technology
Shrink-wrap and click-wrap software licences: contracts of adhesion
A study of on-the-shelf and click-through software licensing contracts and their relationship to contracts of compliance and user protection.

With the emergence of electronic commerce, it has become impossible to follow the traditional method of contracting, in which the parties discuss the terms of the contract before the offer meets acceptance, with regard to many forms of transactions related to goods and services. Trade is often carried out in a rapid manner in which there is not enough time to discuss the terms of the contract.
Traditional contract law is difficult to apply to the sale of computer software, with sellers inventing new ways to make agreements with buyers faster and more efficient.([1])
Below we will explain some types of electronic contracts relevant to online licensing contracts.
The most common types of these contracts are the Shrink-Wrap Contract, and the Click-Wrap Contract. The first is considered the historical source of the second. Below we explain the intended meaning of these contracts and their legal adaptation.
What are the licensing contracts on the cover, and the licensing contracts on the keys:
Explaining the nature of licensing contracts on the cover and licensing contracts on the keys requires clarifying what is meant by the two types of contracts.
1- Licensing contracts on the cover: It is usual when purchasing a computer program to find it enclosed in a plastic cover (cellophane, which is a thin, transparent material that is watertight) bearing a warning that the licensing conditions related to the use of the program are affixed to this cover, and that opening the cover means accepting the terms of the contract attached to it.
Unfortunately for the buyer, the contract in question will be inside the cover, and by opening the cover, the buyer will have accepted the terms in the contract before he can view it.
Such contracts are a convincing way of contracting, but they were never clear, and they did not make the user feel that he was bound by the contract, because no one cared to read the license before opening the cover, nor even after opening it, and perhaps a small number of people kept the license itself, and from here the courts rejected it in the first stage.
It is now well established that licensing contracts on the cover are legally binding contracts. Several rulings have been issued against users who disputed the enforceability of the terms of license contracts on the cover or on the keys on the pretext of not reading them before paying.([2])
An example of rulings issued regarding considering licensing contracts on the cover and licensing contracts on the keys as binding is the case of Prosidi v. Zayed Nabarj.([3]), (ProCD v. Zidenberg). Zeidenberg purchased a personal database from Procede, which came inside a plastic sleeve with a license contract inside, which describes how to use the database. Zeidenberg used some of the Proceedi database data to create his own search engine, which he uploaded to the Internet. Zeidenberg believed that he was not violating the cover license contract because he did not use the protected software that came with the Proceedi database.
Prosidi argued before the lower court that Seidenberg ignored the shell license contract that came with the copy of the software when he started his services website, on which he loaded the search engine, while the license contract prohibited commercial use of the software, and the court held that Seidenberg was not bound by the shell license contract.
However, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, based in Chicago, Illinois, overturned this ruling and ruled that Zeidenberg was bound by the terms of the licensing contract as long as these terms were reasonable.
The court stated that transactions in which payment is made first before notification or statement of detailed conditions are existing and recognized transactions, an example of which is purchasing by phone, as it is impractical to read the terms of sale for each customer individually.
2- Licensing contracts on keys: With the advent of the Internet, programs became easily available for download through websites, and software companies found that they needed to protect themselves from claims for damages resulting from the use of their programs.
So key licensing contracts were created in response to the development of Internet technology and the tremendous growth in its use.
Key license contracts are the electronic equivalent of shell license contracts([4]), because purchasing software via the Internet, or subscribing to website services on the Internet is usually governed by a key licensing contract, and the owners of many websites place on their home page a statement of restrictions on downloading, re-sending or re-using site materials. These restrictions are usually included in the license contract for the keys.
In such previous cases, before the download, subscription, or retransmission process is completed, a window appears on the screen in front of the user, containing the terms of the contract, the rights and obligations of the user and the party that owns the site, ending with a space left to print the acceptance statement. This is the first type of license contract on the keys. The window may end with the phrases (I accept) or (I do not accept) or another similar phrase, and the user is asked to click on one of the two phrases.*, this is the second type of license contract on keys.
As with cover licensing contracts, there are a few cases in the United States related to these contracts, including Hotmail v. Van Mooney Pie.([5])
This case is considered one of the first cases related to licensing contracts on keys. Although the court did not directly deal with the issue of the enforceability of licensing contracts on keys, it implied that the contracts regulating licensing on the Internet are enforceable, meaning that they are enforceable by force of law.
The case concerns Hotmail, an Internet service provider that provides free email services, in exchange for adhering to the conditions set by the services contract. Some of these terms were related to sending spam.
Hotmail learned that the defendants had used the email account for the purpose of sending such unsolicited messages, and Hotmail claimed that this had damaged its reputation after receiving a number of complaints, so it sued Fan MoneyPay.
The court ordered the defendant to stop sending such messages, without issuing a final ruling on whether the defendant had violated the terms of the contract. However, e-commerce operators viewed the court’s decision as a willingness to deal with licensing contracts on keys in the same way it dealt with licensing contracts on the cover.
Both shell licensing contracts and key licensing contracts have advantages and disadvantages, both for the user and for the company using such contracts. However, in general, license contracts on the keys are distinguished from licensing contracts on the cover by several features. They give the user the opportunity to read the terms and conditions of the contract, while license contracts on the cover do not allow this. The user cannot know the terms of the contract until after opening the cover, which is considered acceptance of these terms, and then it is too late to recover the money that was paid.([6]) On the other hand, licensing contracts on keys save the seller the cost of packaging and distribution, and benefit the user, who can now obtain what he wants, whether it is a program or something else, in a much shorter time and at a lower cost.
Such features will make key licensing contracts more popular than shell licensing contracts, while the latter becomes a thing of the past, as it is now common to purchase software over the Internet and download it through it.([7])
However, packaged licensing contracts remain one of the types of contracts used for licensing, even in some cases of software sold over the Internet, if delivery is by normal means.
Legal adaptation of licensing contracts on the cover and licensing contracts on the keys:
Licensing contracts on the cover and licensing contracts on the keys are considered electronic contracts. The question that arises in this area is: Are the aforementioned licensing contracts considered contracts of adhesion? This is considering the presence of the general conditions of sale either on the inside cover or on the website, and the buyer has no choice but to accept them or not to contract at all. This is because contracts of adhesion are contracts whose terms are set by all or most of the powerful party in the contract, and the submissive party cannot amend them or discuss their terms. Acceptance in this case is limited to delivery of a contract whose conditions were prepared in advance by the strong party to the contract.([8])
The Libyan Civil Code stipulates in Article (100) that: “Acceptance in contracts of adhesion is limited to mere delivery of stipulated conditions set by the offeror and no discussion thereof is acceptable.”([9]).
Adhesion contracts are characterized by certain characteristics, which are that they relate to goods or services that are considered necessary for the consumer, and that the offeror has a legal or actual monopoly on these goods or services, or that there is limited competition regarding them, and that the offer is always issued on similar terms, and in the interest of the offeror, and that it is in the form of a previously printed form.([10]).
By reviewing the definition of adhesion contracts and their characteristics, it becomes clear to us that licensing contracts can be considered adhesion contracts as long as the previous characteristics are present in them, if the goods that are the subject of the contract, which are here computer programs, can be considered necessary goods. This issue is relative and relates to the definition of what can be considered necessary goods or not. As for the monopoly condition, it is often indisputable considering that these programs are monopolized by major companies that impose similar conditions on users and are prepared in advance.
Therefore, the absence of legislation regulating cover licensing contracts and key licensing contracts in some countries, such as Libya, makes it conceivable that the rules related to adhesion contracts will be applied to them. Perhaps the judiciary in the future will confirm this conditioning.
In Article (149) and Article (153-2) of the Civil Code, the Libyan legislator has given the judge discretionary power to amend the terms of the contract if they are arbitrary conditions, so it stipulates in Article (149) that: “If the contract was concluded by means of submission and included arbitrary conditions, the judge may amend these conditions or exempt the compliant party from them, in accordance with what justice requires, and any agreement to Otherwise"([11]). On this basis, the judge may amend a condition of the licensing contract or exempt the compliant from it if he considers it an arbitrary condition. Here we note that the American judiciary did not take this aspect into account, and this was clear in the case of Mortensen v. Timberline Software* (Timberline Software Corp v. M.A. Mortenson), the court ruled that the terms of the licensing contract were binding, and thus the stipulated liability exemption clause was applied despite Timberline’s knowledge of the defect in the sold software and the method of remedying it before selling it.
Article (153/2) of the Civil Code stipulates that: “1- Doubt shall be interpreted in the interest of the debtor. 2- However, the interpretation of ambiguous phrases in contracts of adhesion shall not be harmful to the interest of the adhering party.”([12]). Therefore, if a dispute arises regarding one of the conditions of the licensing contract, the doubt is interpreted in the user’s favor.
The possibility of applying the general rules of adhesion contracts to license contracts on the cover and license contracts on the keys does not mean that there is no need for legislative regulation of such contracts, as contracts licensing the use of electronic programs and information that are distributed over the Internet, or those that specify the conditions for the use of on-line services, are considered an essential element of electronic commerce.
It must be taken into account when enacting legislation for electronic commerce to clarify licensing contracts by specifying the rights and obligations of both sellers and buyers over the Internet, as not regulating licensing contracts legislatively may lead to a decrease in confidence in electronic contracting that relies on licenses. We must also benefit from the judicial experiences provided by comparative law to know the most appropriate way to regulate this type of contract, which either applies contract law with its traditional rules regulating written contracts, or who prefers to formulate a special law to regulate electronic contracts.
([1]) See: An article entitled Shrink wrap contract at: http://enwikipedia.org/wiki/Shrink_wrap_contract. (2/23/2008).
([2]) See: Robinson, Steven, article entitled (Security Concerns of Licensing Contracts), at: http://www.secnrityfocus.com/infocu/1602 (2/23/2008).
([3]) See: Ruling of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit cited at: http://www.murdoch.edu.au/elaw/issues/v10n4/halbert104_text.html (2/23/2008).
Also see the same ruling on the website: http://www.design_ireland.net. (7/19/2007).
([4]) See: a previous article on the website: http://www.securityfocns.com/infocus/1602.
* Hence the name click_wrap, as approval is achieved by clicking (click) on the approval key.
([5]) See: a ruling referred to on the website: http://www.design_ireland.net.(7/19/2007).
([6]) See: Callan,David article entitled (How Key Licensing Contracts Are Different from Wrap Licensing Contracts) at: http://www.akamarketing.com/click-wrap-shrink-wrap_contracts.html. (2/23/2008)
([7]) See: An article entitled (Advantages of licensing contracts on the keys over licensing contracts on the cover) on the website:
http://www.design-ireland.net. (7/19/2007).
([8]) See: Al-Badawi, Muhammad Ali, The General Theory of Commitment, Libya: National Book House, 2nd edition, Part One, 1997, p. 68.
([9]) See: Encyclopedia of Libyan Legislation (Civil Law), previous reference, p. 28.
([10]) See: Al-Badawi, Muhammad Ali, previous reference, p. 69.
([11]) See: Encyclopedia of Libyan Legislation (Civil Law), previous reference, p. 38.
Available at: http://www.murdoch.edu.au/elaw/issues/v10n4/halbert104_text.html (2/23/2008).
([12]) See: Encyclopedia of Libyan Legislation (Civil Law), previous reference, p. 39.
Article contributors
What does this mean for your business?
Discuss the issue with our team and understand the advice relevant to your matter.
Discuss this topic



